Whiskey Shots: Watershed Barrel Strength Fall Finishing Series Bourbon Finished in Apple Brandy Barrels

🥃 129.2 Proof

🥃 Aged 6 Years, Finished in Apple Brandy Barrels

🥃 750 ml bottle purchased directly from the distillery

🥃 Tasted in my Bourbon Real Talk High-Proof Whiskey Tasting Glass

As I uncorked this bottle, I felt a sense of eager anticipation. It had been calling out to me ever since I first laid eyes on it. Having previously tasted and reviewed their blended bourbon, which features a harmonious mix of 4-year bourbon, 6-year apple brandy barrel finished bourbon, and high rye sourced bourbon at 90 proof (https://www.whiskeybygeorge.com/post/whiskey-shots-a-review-of-watershed-blended-bourbon-finished-in-apple-brandy-barrels), I was curious to see how this high-proof offering would stand on its own.

Nose

The first whiff transported me back to the cozy holidays of my youth, with aromas of spiced apple rings filling the glass. The warmth of oak was unmistakable, providing a robust backbone, while a delicate hint of caramel teased the senses. It was an inviting and nostalgic nose that promised a rich and layered tasting experience.

Palate

Upon taking my first sip, the cinnamon-spiced apples were immediately front and center, delivering a punch of flavor that was both bold and lively. However, the sweetness I had anticipated from the nose did not fully materialize. Instead, a drying oakiness quickly followed, asserting itself more than I had expected. The caramel that had whispered its presence in the nose became a mere whisper on the palate, hard to pinpoint amidst the stronger, more dominant flavors.

Finish

The finish was long and dry, leaving a peppery tingle that lingered on the tongue. It was an intriguing end, adding complexity but also reinforcing the drying oak that had been prominent throughout the tasting.

---

While this bourbon certainly has its unique characteristics and complexities, I found myself slightly disappointed. I had high hopes, especially given my enjoyment of their blended bourbon, but this particular expression didn't quite hit the mark for me. The drying oak and elusive caramel left me wanting a bit more balance. For now, I can’t go higher than a 3.8 out of 5 stars. However, I plan to let it rest on the shelf for a month or two before revisiting. Sometimes, a bit of patience can reveal hidden depths, and I’m hopeful that this bourbon might just surprise me yet. Cheers to the journey of discovery! 🥃